Ask Tim · Home Value & Pricing
Is it a buyer's market or a seller's market in Castro Valley right now?
Answered by Tim Fiebig, Broker, DRE #00657474
Last updated November 13, 2026 Whether the market leans toward buyers or sellers comes down to three things: how much inventory is for sale, how fast homes are selling, and which way prices are moving. My September 2026 market report, the same numbers I mail to Castro Valley neighbors in the Dear Neighbor postcard, gives the current picture.
The median sale price was about $1.1 million, down roughly 6% from a year earlier. Homes averaged about 29 days on market, compared with a national average of 56 days.
Volume stayed steady, with about 471 homes sold over the past 12 months (Homes.com, September 2026). A common rule of thumb is that under about three months of supply tends to favor sellers, while five months or more tends to favor buyers.
Castro Valley's pace, homes going under contract in about a month, tells you supply is nowhere near a glut. At the same time, prices have eased, and buyers who have been waiting have more to choose from and more room to negotiate terms, not just price.
So the honest label is a seller's market that has cooled. What that means for you: a home priced against real recent sales, prepared and staged well, and launched with pre-market exposure can still draw serious offers in its first weeks.
A home priced a notch too high, or one that sits and goes stale, is the one where buyers set the terms. I update these numbers every month in the market report, so this answer changes over time.
If you are deciding whether to list now or wait, ask me for the current month's figures for your neighborhood and I will show you which way this market is actually leaning for your home.
Ask Tim about your home
Questions like this one are exactly what Tim answers every day for Castro Valley sellers. Call or text him at 510-708-8700, or send a message and he will get back to you personally.
Send Tim a message
Tell Tim about your home, your goals, or your timeline. He reads every message personally and replies fast.