Ask Tim · Home Value & Pricing
Should I list high and lower the price later?
Answered by Tim Fiebig, Broker, DRE #00657474
Last updated November 13, 2026 Usually not, and I will tell you why plainly. A new listing gets its strongest attention in the first two to three weeks.
That is when the online portals push it to the most buyers, when agents are most likely to preview it, and when the market decides whether it is priced right. If the price is too high, the buyers who would have paid a fair price scroll past it, and the buyers who do look compare it against better-priced homes and move on.
After a few weeks, the listing starts to look stale, and buyers start to wonder what is wrong with it. By the time you reduce the price, you are marketing a home that the market has already judged, and the reduction often has to be bigger than the original overpricing to get attention.
In a market where well-priced Castro Valley homes average about 29 days on market (Homes.com, September 2026), the cost of a pricing mistake is measured in weeks of lost exposure. I have written about this in detail in my article on the $50,000 pricing mistake, and it comes down to one rule: price against today's sales, not against what you hope the market will do.
If you want to test a slightly higher price, we can talk about the risk and the exact number at which the risk is worth taking. Most of the time, pricing it right on day one is the highest-price strategy there is.
Ask Tim about your home
Questions like this one are exactly what Tim answers every day for Castro Valley sellers. Call or text him at 510-708-8700, or send a message and he will get back to you personally.
Send Tim a message
Tell Tim about your home, your goals, or your timeline. He reads every message personally and replies fast.