Ask Tim · Offers & Closing
What happens if I get multiple offers?
Answered by Tim Fiebig, Broker, DRE #00657474
Last updated November 13, 2026 Multiple offers are a good problem to have, and they need a clear process. When more than one buyer wants your home, I compare every offer on more than the price: financing strength, contingencies, deposit, and timing.
The highest number is not always the best offer. A slightly lower offer with strong financing and no inspection contingency can be safer and close faster than a higher offer that depends on the buyer selling their own home first.
Once we have all the offers, I may ask the buyers for their highest and best, which gives everyone one clean chance to put their strongest terms forward. Then I lay out each offer for you in plain language: what it pays, how likely it is to close, and what the timeline looks like, and we pick the one that best fits your goals.
Sometimes that is the highest price. Sometimes it is the offer with the fewest conditions.
Sometimes it is the buyer who can close in two weeks. In a market where Castro Valley homes average about 29 days on market (Homes.com, September 2026), well-priced homes regularly draw multiple offers, so this is not a rare situation.
My job is to make sure you understand what each offer really means before you sign, and to protect your position through the inspection, appraisal and escrow stages, because the strongest offer on paper still needs to close. That is where experience shows up.
Ask Tim about your home
Questions like this one are exactly what Tim answers every day for Castro Valley sellers. Call or text him at 510-708-8700, or send a message and he will get back to you personally.
Send Tim a message
Tell Tim about your home, your goals, or your timeline. He reads every message personally and replies fast.