Ask Tim · Offers & Closing
What if the appraisal comes in low?
Answered by Tim Fiebig, Broker, DRE #00657474
Last updated November 13, 2026 A low appraisal is not the end of the deal, but it does force a decision. When the home appraises below the agreed price, the buyer's lender will only finance up to the appraised value, so the gap has to be covered somehow.
The common options are to renegotiate the price down to the appraisal, to have the buyer cover the difference in cash, or to split the difference between you. Sometimes the buyer walks away if the gap is too large and they cannot or will not cover it.
The best defense is prevention: a list price supported by real comparable sales is far less likely to come in low, because the appraiser looks at the same sales I priced from. That is why I price from recent closed sales in your neighborhood, adjusted for condition, size, lot and views, and why I can show you the evidence behind the price before we list.
If an appraisal does come in low, I do not just accept it. I review the appraisal report for errors: wrong square footage, wrong comparables, missed upgrades, or a comparable from the wrong neighborhood.
Appraisals can be challenged with good evidence, and I have done that successfully. If the value genuinely is not there, we negotiate from a position of knowing exactly what the market says.
Either way, you are never guessing, and you always know what the appraisal really means for your proceeds.
Ask Tim about your home
Questions like this one are exactly what Tim answers every day for Castro Valley sellers. Call or text him at 510-708-8700, or send a message and he will get back to you personally.
Send Tim a message
Tell Tim about your home, your goals, or your timeline. He reads every message personally and replies fast.